Ninja Kamae Vs Karate Stances - Understanding the Difference Between Dynamics and Mere Mechanics

Almost everyone who knows anything about theThe Japanese word for "stance" is tachi. It can
martial arts is familiar with the idea of "stances."also be pronounced dachi as the second syllable in
And, to the average person who tends to calla word, phrase, or term.
every martial art, regardless of actual name,The word tachi or dachi typically refers to the
"ka-roddy," these stances are nothing more thanposition of the body from the waist down. It
the static body poses that you will fight from.usually represents or implies a starting position.
Hence, the commonly referred to term of,While the word kamae literally means "posture."
"Fighting stances."The kanji itself means, "base." Where tachi
And while, to the untrained eye of the beginner orpointed to the "starting position" and the position
casual observer, they may look the same, whatof the lower body, kamae points to the posture
few people understand is that the body posturesof the "entire body." This includes not only the
of Ninjutsu are, in reality, very different from thephysical posture, but also the posture of the mind,
conventional "stances" used in almost all of thespirit, and attitude of the Ninja defender.
commonly available fighting styles out there today.The easiest way to understand kamae is by
In fact, most people, including students new tounderstanding that you are never NOT in kamae.
the art of ninjutsu, tend to see these "poses" asAnd, while I talk about this in other related
merely "necessary evils" to be gone through andarticles, suffice it to say here that, while a tachi is
learned so that they can get to the really "coolsomething to be "taken up," to be "constructed"...
stuff." And, it's only after years of training, orYour kamae is something that comes from the
making the breakthrough to the level ofinside - out. It is not something arbitrarily chosen.
understanding that is required for Mastery, doesBut rather, your kamae - the physical position of
the student realize that these basic pieces of theyour body that is visible to the world - is a
art...reflection of what is going on in your head and in
ARE the "cool stuff."your heart.
To understand the difference between theSo, we could say that the difference between
"karate stance" and the Ninja's "kamae"the stances of "karate," and the postures of the
(pronounced "kah-mah-eh" or sometimes,Ninja's self defense arts is that:
"kah-my"), we only need to look at the Japanese1)The tachi (dashi) is something taken up as a
word used to describe each, and thestarting point, while...
Sino-Japanese kanji character used to write it out.2)The Ninja's kamae are "states of being" -
This is a good place to begin a deep levelsingular unifications of the body, mind, and spirit
understanding of almost any of the concepts,aligned in the same direction - to be recognized
principles, and exotic skills found in the martial artsand used as tools for the successful
of Japan.accomplishment of the task at hand.
And, Ninjutsu is no exception.