Karate-Style Punching Or Street Attack - Can You Really Defend Yourself Against a Real Attacker?

One of the most common statements that I hearOkay?
from both Ninjutsu students, as-well-as thoseThe question is: "What kind of punch are you
training in other 'traditional' forms of martial arts is,most likely to deal with - to have thrown at you -
"I'm not looking for modern self defenseduring a street fighting or street self defense
techniques. I'll just stick to the classical approach."situation?"
This article addresses several flaws in thisA karate front punch?
approach to real-world self defense training in theA ninpo-taijutsu "tsuki?"
21st century.A White Crane Kung-fu finger-tip strike?
After you've finished reading this article, your jobNope.
will be to assess, with a critical eye, your currentA good old right-cross!
training, and more importantly, your understandingThat's not my opinion. That's the cold, hard reality
of that training, to see whether or not you areof today's world!
really prepared to protect yourself against a realAnd, this isn't an argument over me telling you
attack, from a real attacker, in today's real worldthat you should train in my system - an
- and NOT 16th century Japan, Korea, China, orego-based idea that says that, "If I do it, then it's
wherever your art originated!right, and you should be doing the same thing" -
Please know that I am not criticizing any style ofbut rather a lesson that comes from experience
martial arts, or approach to self defense. What Iknowing what happens on the street. Because, if
am driving at, is the need to see beyond theyou don't know what it's really like inside of a real
"models" that were passed down from ancientattack - not a sport or competition setting that's
times, and be able to see how the lessons - theloaded with rules and safety measures - then you
principles and concepts - that the models arecan never know if what you're learning will actually
teaching, would, should, and could be applied today.work outside of the dojo, dojang, or self defense
It's one thing to be able to execute your art'sclass!
snapping, front punch, or in the case of theDo you understand?
modern Ninjutsu student's so-called "classical" tsukiDo you get the significance of this apparently
(pronounced: 'ski'), which was originally designed tosimple, little lesson?
be effective while wearing, or while dealing withI hope so. Because, the question IS NOT: "Are
an opponent who was wearing ancient armor...you learning self defense?"
...and being able to quickly, easily, and effectivelyThe REAL question is...
punch a modern-day street thug who doesn't"While you're practicing against the "official,"
care one iota about where you train, the art or"classical," and "proper" strikes from your martial
style that you have a Black Belt in, or where thatarts' style...
style came from. Not one bit!...are you learning how to not get your lights
The same thing goes for your defense tacticsturned off by the guy who doesn't punch like
against a punch.they do in class?!
To illustrate this point, let me ask you a question.